Nobody on a deal team uses a tie-out for the same reason. Pick your seat.
MDnever touches it
VPverifies it
Associatechecks it
Analystbuilds it
click a rung
The Analyst — 11 p.m., building the set
The one you actually live in.
It's 11 p.m. You're building the comp set. The associate reviews it at 7 a.m. Every mistake is yours until someone catches it — and you'd rather catch it yourself.
Build your own spread first, then compare. Run the ticker, see where your hand-built version disagrees with the sourced one, and find out why before your associate does.
Never get caught flat on "where's this from." Every adjustment is already tied to the statement or note it came from — you're not scrambling to find the footnote at 7:05 a.m.
Stop manually re-tying adjusted EBITDA by hand. The reconciliation against management's own disclosed number is already done — check it once, move on to the next name in the set.
Learn the judgment calls, not just the arithmetic. Every non-mechanical adjustment shows its reasoning — so the pattern sticks for the next ticker, and the one after that.
The moment it matters: the twenty minutes before you send the comp set upstairs, when you're not sure if you missed something.
The Associate — 7 a.m., checking the set
The consistency police.
Three analysts built ten comps between them. Somewhere in there, someone added back stock comp on one name and forgot it on another — and it's your name on the set when it goes to the VP.
Run the full peer set, not one ticker at a time. See whether the same adjustment got the same treatment across every name — before it's your problem in review.
Catch the inconsistency, not just the error. A wrong number is bad. A comp set where five names treat restructuring one way and five treat it another is worse — and much harder to spot by eye.
Hand up one clean set, not a patchwork. Normalize the whole peer group to one house convention instead of stitching together whatever each analyst happened to do.
Redirect your review time. Spend it on the judgment calls that actually need a second opinion, not re-deriving arithmetic that already ties.
The moment it matters: the hour before the deck freezes, cross-checking ten names against each other instead of ten names against the filing.
The VP — two hours before the client call
The gut-check before the meeting.
You're not opening Excel two hours before a client call. You need one number, verified, and you need it fast enough that nobody notices you checked.
Pull the bridge up on your phone. Confirm the number your team gave you actually holds — in the elevator, not at your desk.
Spot-check one name in a fifteen-comp set. Without re-underwriting the other fourteen, or asking the analyst to walk you through it.
Know the footnote before anyone asks for it. If a client questions a number on the page, you already know exactly which disclosure backs it — because you checked, not because you're guessing.
Push back on your own team with specifics. "This doesn't tie to their reconciliation" lands very differently than "this looks off."
The moment it matters: the fifteen minutes before you walk into a room where you can't afford to be wrong.
The MD — thirty seconds before the room
The one you never touch, until you need to.
You don't build models. You haven't opened a comp set from scratch in years. But you're the one who says the number out loud in front of the client, and you're the one it reflects on if it's wrong.
Thirty seconds before you walk in. Confirm the number your team handed you actually ties, without making them explain it to you again.
Answer a challenge on the spot. If a client or board member pushes on a figure mid-meeting, you already know where it came from — you're not stalling for someone to text you the source.
Never need to ask if it's been checked. The number that reaches you has already been tied out — you're confirming, not trusting blind.
Nobody upstream of you ever finds out you looked. It's private, it's fast, and it doesn't go through the team you're quietly double-checking.
The moment it matters: the one time a number is wrong in front of a client — which is the only time anyone remembers.